Just over a week ago I finished reading Donald Miller’s
Searching for God Knows What. Earlier tonight Amanda and I finished reading
The Half Blood Prince. I don’t know with which ending I am most disappointed.
One peaks with an analysis of Romeo and Juliet as a deeply profound retelling of Christian reconciliation. (For those of you who haven’t read either Miller’s or Rowling’s books, I won’t say which one. Oh, and climb out from under your rock.) I loved the book and was a bit let down by this “let me prove I was an English major” stretch that, while I could accept the premise, seemed so unlike the rest of the text. Having forced my share of comparisons – Ngugi/Wordsworth, Mau Mau Rebellion/Industrial Revolution, The Tick/The Nixon Presidency – I proudly admit to the plank in my eye but offer my disappointment nonetheless.
The other book was an equally engrossing book that I also loved reading. My disappointment came with the “now you’re forced to by the next book whether you want to or not” ending. What kind of
Back to the Future II kind of closure is that? And now I have to wait another six months to, maybe, get some resolution.
Oh, and if you dig Miller’s lifeboat metaphor (which I really did) you might want to try reading Yann Martel’s
Life of Pi. Better yet, skip the whole lifeboat thing and take an elevator with Colson Whitehead’s
The Intuitionist.